Sarasota, FL

MarinaJack in Sarasota, FL
Sarasota gradually grew around the docks as originally it had only ferry access from Tampa; there were no roads to it. Those docks were eventually developed into the largest marina on Florida’s west coast by Jack Graham, thus its name. Alto offered down-town living and Yelp described
42 bars and restaurants within just 1800 feet of her slip! But as Gail’s ambulation and balance were worsening, living on a boat was no longer an option. So after four years of looking
Stacks Image 12
Jerry finally found and renovated a small in-town condo. A major feature was that it was just a 12-minute Uber ride from the local airport, SRQ, and direct flights from Providence or Boston could get us there in under three hours.

Sarasota met most of my criteria: It was a small, beautiful city not too crowded even in the winter season and walkable with over 400 bars and cafés – many with outdoor seating. There were dozens of theaters, an opera and even nearby National League baseball winter training ballparks. It was charming and elegant, but the Bentleys and Lamborghinis everywhere indicated how wealthy you needed to be to live with water views in the tall condos. And there are no in-town beaches, although some of the best beaches in the world are on nearby Siesta and Long Boat Keys. Still, living on a boat made it affordable and fun, but incredibly hot in the summers given full sun exposure.

Sarasota had never been directly hit by a hurricane, until it was in 2025. But in 2024 on Cape Cod in the off season we watched anxiously as climate warming caused
five hurricane warnings in the Gulf. Alto II was too big to pull out of the water preemptively, so Jerry made plans to sell her and buy a smaller Ranger Tug which could be trailered. After all, he didn’t need such a big boat since there was now a condo to live in. We even bought a second as an investment and renovated it too.

Then Hurricane Helene, a cat. 3/4 storm passed by and produced 10 foot surges that flipped over the concrete floating finger dock Alto II was tied to. Amazingly, she had been sold and moved just the day before!!! Just, a week later Hurricane Milton (cat. 3) destroyed the nearby Keys and a good deal of the city. Through it all, Alto III did well safely sitting on her trailer, out of the water.

It was all too much and suddenly, after ten years of watching the Cape Cod real estate market, Tidewatch came available. We’ve had only two hurricanes on the Cape in the last 35 years. In 1991 Hurricane Bob, a cat. 2 storm, wrecked Jerry’s little sailboat in Cotuit Bay. It was the most intense storm since 1938, but still only a cat. 2. We’ve had many serious storms since, but only Hurricane Irene’s (2011) off-shore winds, Sandy’s (2012) heavy rain, and Debby’s rip currents and rain has caused any significant damage. Cape Cod in New England just isn’t at risk like Florida for hurricanes – remember in 2024 there were five potential hits on Sarasota. Having a boat sitting in Florida waters over the summer was too stressful for us.

So we bought Tidewatch, towed Alto III to our home on Cape Cod and sold the Florida. It seems weird to own a waterfront vacation condo just 18 minutes from our Cotuit home, which we now share with a few summer renters. Jerry doesn’t miss it since he has Alto III in the Nantucket Sound and Gail prefers living on land in our main house in Cotuit.

Just to verify this was the right move, after selling the last Sarasota condo Jerry drove the mighty Honda Fit back to Cape Cod looking at alternatives to Tidewatch all along the way. He wondered if he could find greener grass (a better beach house) on the east coast to live as a retirement spot.
Spoiler Alert: he found no better place for oceanfront living with beach access than Tidewatch. At least he found nothing that was not on stilts or in a new high-rise condo building, with a nearby village with some charm that could compete with TW. For you, gentle reader who might be skeptical, he documents the trip here:

Starting the journey, Jerry skipped the Keys (been there and done that) and the east coast of Florida as Miami Beach, Hollywood Beach, Fort Lauderdale, the Palm Beaches, the Hutchinson islands, Melbourne Beach, Cape Canaveral, Cocoa Beach, etc. just did not meet his criteria. In the past his parents had water view condos on Highland Beach (near Delray) and on Jupiter Island so he knew those areas well.

In a nutshell, the hurricane threat in Florida for a boater, not to mention mandatory hurricane evacuation 50-miles inland, compromised living there full-time. Also, the fear of older condo buildings (think the Miami Surfside Condo collapse in 2021) meant brand new, slick condo buildings thus destroying the charm factor. Houses on stilts were a no-go. Also, there was another
huge problem with oceanfront living in Florida:

Florida: No Longer a Realistic Option
It’s worth addressing Florida’s new Milestone Inspection Law which mandates any condo building over two stories that is 25-30 years old must be inspected by independent engineers looking for future issues. To justify their fees, they always find stuff just like a buyer’s home inspection. They are looking for “future” not just current problems. The issue is that condo associations must establish adequate reserves to cover any predicted preventive maintenance within two years.

So when an inspector says you need a new roof within the next decade, special assessments must be paid within two years to reserve adequate funds for that eventual expense; i.e. you can be hit with massive assessments that need to be paid within a year or two even though there is no immediate problem. Even tile roofs need replacement every 25 years, and all concrete walls develop “spalling” requiring repair/prevention. Being on the salt ocean means rust everywhere. And, you can’t budget for any of it.

All buildings will need maintenance, but now you must pay in advance for predicted issues, not deal with problems as they come up. BTW the Inspection Law, being Republican in nature, ruled out any bailouts or state-funding for loans to owners facing massive special assessments due in a year or two. All condo buildings over two stories near the ocean need their first inspection at 25-30 years of age, and then every ten years after. A time bomb awaits any condo unless, like our Sarasota properties, they are in a one- or two-story building.

So newer buildings are now unaffordable since they are built better and don’t have to be inspected right away, while units in older condo buildings are unsellable due to risk of future inspection discoveries. No one can plan for special assessments, they occur instantly on an inspector’s whim. Gail’s ambulation problems precluded a single-family home on stilts (who wants that anyway), and mandatory evacuations for living in a flood zone (that’s nearly all coastal homes) was a deal killer for Jerry. So, salt waterfront living anywhere in Florida is out.

So Where Else?
Driving up to the Cape from Florida, Jerry’s goal was to explore the Sea Islands, which are over 100 tidal and barrier reef islands from northern Florida through Georgia, and South & North Carolina. Settled thousands of years ago they are where the Gullah Geechee people still live, who of course are being gentrified out of existence. Still they were intriguing with lots of beach, potential for charm and no Milestone Laws.

Lets visit the Sea Islands up the east coast of the US beginning with Fernandina Beach on Amelia Island in the following section.
RapidWeaver Icon

Availability for 2027!